Sunday, September 2, 2012

The Wire: Reformation (S3:E10)


“But as a shorty I looked up to the dopeman / only adult-man I knew that wasn’t broke, man”

            The beauty of “The Wire” lies not just in its grander attributes, its social commentary, its constant callbacks to continuity, and its creation of a credible and cromulent (…and I’m done) Baltimore, but also in it’s simple pulp writing. The little things, like the constant repetition of “man” as a punctuating statement to many lines of dialogue in this episode (it’s only overtly obvious when Snoop says it, but you can see it’s almost everywhere if you’re looking for it). It’s rhythmic, and it sort of hints at a going battle that’s present almost everywhere in the episode: what would a “real man” do?
            There are two places where this is most obvious. The first is an interesting blink-and-you’ll-miss-it shot of Commander Rawls at a gay bar, clearly feeling comfortable and in his element. I’m not sure how I feel about this, for a reason that always makes me uncomfortable in the show: it seems to be hinting at the grander theme that “sexual orientation (but you could just as well say “race” or “gender”) doesn’t matter.” On one hand, this is a great sentiment: much better characters not be defined crudely as “gay,” or “black.” But it seems to me to be lacking in the other direction: I don’t think race/gender/orientation is merely an add-on of a trait, and that all of them are, in fact, rather important to one’s identity. I digress: it’s literally just a second, but it’s one that does get at one of the maybe two or three things that really bug me about the show.
            The other (at least obvious) place is with Cutty’s attempts to build up his boxing gym. The kids come in, and Cutty, who has much more experience with murder than he does with childcare, can’t quite handle the little rascals. He gets angry, insults them, and they leave. Luckily, Cutty has enough people willing to provide the advice he needs to hear, and the “don’t be willing to let them fail” is a particularly good one (especially seeing the season that follows this one). Chad Coleman, the actor who portrays Cutty, can go from “terrifying mass of man” to “strong father figure” at the drop of a hat, which says a ton about his presence. Cutty isn’t much for words, but he realizes that physical strength doesn’t (or must not) always lead to a life as a soldier, and maybe Justin (the boy who returns to the gym) can learn well from him.
            If we view masculinity as sort of a traditional position of righteous leadership, which is admittedly enough of a dicey point where I’m going to mostly drop the thread, we can see this battle at play amongst Stringer, Avon, and Marlo. Marlo, of course, continues his path towards being the most despicable character on the show, executing Devonne (who previously betrayed him) with three gun shots, one in each breast and one in the mouth. It’s violence as sexual dominance, which should come as no surprise having seen Marlo’s earlier sex scene.
            Marlo’s clearly the dark underbelly of what the “men” in the game do, making Stringer and Avon the good guys merely by position. Of course, we see Stringer betraying his life-long friend and partner to the police on behalf of the business, a terribly underhanded move that nonetheless makes a good degree of sense. I think Avon’s code is a ton more likeable than String, but look at it from an unbiased perspective: if Avon gets what he wants, their business seems like it will collapse, many more people will die, and my hunch would be that Avon and Stringer both go down with the ship. Stringer’s Machiavellian plans may seem terrible, but they make a good degree of sense (the grand tragedy is that the guy who is best at “the game” is also the one most eager to get out of it).
            Then, of course, we have the biggest part of the episode: the confession of Hamsterdam by Bunny. It was inevitable, as someone was bound to find out about a mass-scale drug legalization program, but its descent isn’t as quick as he may have assumed. Seeing Rawls and Burrell scramble to cover their asses, without a single concern as to what the benefits are of doing so. Of course, government isn’t completely without a tie to reality, and his use of public letters draws a surprisingly supportive responsive from a desperate Royce campaign. Everyone’s a selfish schmuck in their own way (Rawls perhaps the least, getting the joy he does out of what happens), but still…

“Call it a crisis of leadership” –Prop Joe

Observations and What-Have-You’s

n  Carcetti feels really guilty about having to betray Anthony Gray in order to win the nomination for mayor. He’s right, of course, about basically everything: he’s the best of the three candidates (Gray lacks the tack, and Royce is too apathetic), and honesty would ruin his chances. He’s a political sociopath, surely, but he has emotions and functional loyalties: nice to see them when they pop up.
n  Prop Joe cuts out Stringer: democracy has its downsides when you’re on the wrong side of public sentiment.
n  McNulty is still upset about his failed relationship with D’Agostino, who seems to think she’s better than him. “The Wire” has an interesting relationship with the world outside of Baltimore: the connections are hinted at, through the docks, the approach of NY gangs, but, save for the concluding shot of Omar in the Bronx to Season One, Wallace in suburban Md., and a plotline I’m not going to discuss in Season Five, we never leave. It’s a proudly local show, and McNulty’s anger at D’Agostino (read: Washington, DC) is also the showrunner’s (David Simon almost didn’t hire George Pelacanos, the writer of the show’s next episode. As a warning, it’s one of the show’s best, and the first to be nominated for an Emmy).